Bruno Mars’ most recent album, The Romantic, is the tale of a love story in all its phases. From reconciled fights to groovy dance floors, the album is thematically classic Mars—but doesn’t hold a candle to his previous hits.

In the album’s only single, “I Just Might,” Mars draws heavily upon jazz influences. Brass instruments and a plethora of percussion exist to be danced to, as Mars scats and belts with a croon. The bridge is notably reminiscent of his earlier song “24K Magic,” though more wholesome: “Put some spirit in it, put your heart into it, that’s all I need.”

Likewise, in “Cha Cha Cha,” Mars embraces his Latin heritage, blending the congas and cowbell with orchestral brass. It’s soulful, but falls short past the second chorus. What’s missing is a climax, as is also the case in “Why You Wanna Fight?” and “God Was Showing Off.”

Though the album is filled with joyful beats, Mars generally misses the mark with his slower ballads: neither evoke the same sincerity from previous records, nor do they exist to be belted in the shower. Mars’ lyrics are less relatable to a general audience, and might suit the aftermath of a heated argument over dish-washing: “We can work this out, don’t say that it’s through.”

The Romantic bears Mars’ fingerprints, but lacks the endearing nature of Doo-Wops & Hooligans or the unshakable confidence of 24K Magic. Unfortunately for Mars, the bar was set just above his fingertips; and he seems content to rest there comfortably.